Why the need to keep frequently reiterating this story??? It is not as though anyone would doubt this, surely?I, as we all know quite well, have only been on this forum since 2018,...
Ian.
Why the need to keep frequently reiterating this story??? It is not as though anyone would doubt this, surely?I, as we all know quite well, have only been on this forum since 2018,...
Honestly, Ian, you never know of what some people manage to convince themselves.It is not as though anyone would doubt this, surely?
Ian.
So very true ....Honestly, Ian, you never know of what some people manage to convince themselves.
Hi.Probably, look at the size of the seal though. A car hoist isn't rated for constant use. Even in a commercial environment, they would go up and down .... a dozen times a day? compared to say a ram on an excavator, that would be in constant movement.
I have run a hone up and down it, its mostly quite clean below the "return" hole at the top of the ram (that will prevent it lifting to high). There is probably 3cm of sealing surface along the sides of the seal (rather than a fraction of a millimeter from an Oring).
It will be interesting to see how long it works for. I'm pretty sure it would work fine for now even with the probably 50year old heavily worn seal re-installed. With a new seal, it will hopefully outlive me
Worst case, I find another scrap metal hoist and start another projectThere was a molner 4post with two sliding jacks last week on fb marketplace for~$1000. I would just put my existing pump on it ......
seeya
Shane L.
Hi jaahn.Hydraulic cylinders on normal machinery might not be as well made as you might hope, depending on the quality and the application. I have had a few apart and repaired them. Most agriculture and similar rams like the hoist are just seamless steel tube with a hone finish. The rods are usually hard chromed to repel dirt. But even on back hoes and the like a dissemble, clean and new seals will get them leak free and working ok even if the rods are a bit scored. The cylinders are normally ok if the dirt did not get in or water pooled in there. After all the things should be full of oil when operating.
Keep the water off the seals would be my recommendation !
cheers. jaahn
these rams look to be built like junk to me. It looks like a length of standard mild steel tube. they use a big chunky seal to ride over any flaws in the steel. Nothing hardened. You could make it yourself probably. Actually, not junk. Its probably 50years old and still going strong. Its a car hoist, it never needs to worry about wear, heat, cold, duty cycle etc. There really is no duty cycle requirements for a hoist, so you dont' need fancy high wear proof parts. Its all just mild steel from what I can tell. Ram, piston .... well the entire thingHi jaahn.
My understanding is the hard chroming of the cylinder rods is mainly as a more durable wearing bearing surface and also to reduce/prevent rusting. The oil floods the microcracks in the chrome and seals the carbon steel from oxygen. Hence the need to cycle the rods every now and again to wet them with oil. It's the gland wiper that removes dirt from the rod.
Cheers.